Browse By

The Weather Underground

I just finished watching a documentary called The Weather Underground. It’s about 90 minutes long, and covers a small set of radicals (the inappropriately named Weathermen, since leadership included a number of women) who split off from the 60s organization Students for a Democratic Society (SDS), declared that violent means were not only necessary but preferred as a way of bringing about revolution in the United States, went into hiding, destroyed property in symbolic solidarity with a dizzying array of causes (but didn’t as a group kill anyone, although after the group broke up a few members went on to kill people), then gave it up as the 70s came to a close.

I recommend this documentary to you not because it definitively makes the case that the Weather Underground was morally right or morally bankrupt. It’s a great documentary because it captures so well the starkly different ethical shades of 30-40 years ago. Both law enforcement and activists make arguments and assumptions that wouldn’t make sense today, or at least wouldn’t seem to. In interviews, former members of the Underground are reflective and self-critical to varying extents about their involvement. Todd Gitlin, who usually bugs the shit out of me for his paternalistic “let me tell you about how we did it in the sixties, younguns” schtick, really nails one facet of the Weather Underground when he speaks in this DVD: a group of insulated, self-referencing people who become so convinced of their rectitude that they become willing to engage in methodological violence to achieve substantive ends, and who did not grasp the irony of their choices until too late, if at all.

This is not a propaganda film, it’s not a documentary meant to make you believe anything. It’s much more shaded than that, much more shaded than the Weather Underground itself. For the first time in a long time, I’ve been provoked into a serious spate of thought by something I’ve seen on a television screen.

3 thoughts on “The Weather Underground”

  1. Sarge says:

    jmathew, do you remember the “Pentagon Papers” flap? I think that one of the reasons it so incensed my father was that the “papers” showed that the Weathermen, SDS, and other peaceniks had been right all along! It mostly WAS to “generate income” for certain corperations.

    There it was, in boring, banal language, the reason all that treasure and blood were being expended.

  2. Tomas says:

    Well (former) general Smedley Butler could’ve told us that back in the 1930s. Actually he did, saying he was part of the biggest racket in the world, the U.S. military, saying that basically everything he did was done in the interest of U.S. corporations like helping pacify Nicaragua in the 1920s for Brown Brothers banking interests etc. He said something like, “The flag follows the corporations and the soldier follows the flag”.

  3. Pingback: Irregular Times: News Unfit for Print » Clandestine Underground Anti-War Group Issues Press Release?
  4. Trackback: Irregular Times: News Unfit for Print » Clandestine Underground Anti-War Group Issues Press Release?

Leave a Reply to Tomas Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Psst... what kind of person doesn't support pacifism?

Fight the Republican beast!