Speculation Drives Oil Down Too
How do you like that 70 dollar barrel of oil? Yes, oil is trading at less than half the price it was just a few months ago.
Why? Well, the economy is predicted to go down, and so oil traders speculate that there will be decreased demand for fossil fuels…
Oh, hold on a second. They speculate that there will be a decreased demand for fossil fuels? That’s what’s driving down the price? So that would suggest that the doubling of the price of oil over the last year was due to speculation as well, wouldn’t it?
If we can cut the price of oil in half just with a few weeks of positive speculation, we never really needed the “drill, baby, drill” chants for no-limits offshore drilling, did we?
I think that there’s a good argument to be made for the idea that, although the current financial crisis is founded broadly upon problems in credit markets, that the economic stress that provoked the breakdown in credit markets was the rapid inflation in the price of gasoline and other oil-based energy products. That provoked inflation in other goods, which led to a drop-off in consumption, which led to layoffs and business closures, which led to a heckuva a lot of precarious credit being tipped over the edge into downright bad credit.
A lot of people are calling for increased regulation of credit markets. That’s fine, but congressional investigations followed by increased regulation of energy markets seem to be needed to. The hypercapitalist faith in the genius of the market place has not been vindicated… unless you categorize what’s happened to the economy as the result of oil speculation as evil genius.