Browse By

Credulity over Credibility: Fox News Flubs the Prahlad Jani Story

Yesterday morning, Fox News issued a news story on the Prahlad Jani “miracle”: that apparently the 83 year old man hasn’t eaten a morsel or had a drop to drink since World War II. Fox News reported on a recently concluded episode in which Prahlad Jani was said to be constantly observed by scientists in a research unit of the Indian military:

An Indian holy man has amazed a team of doctors by not eating or drinking anything for two weeks.

Prahlad Jani, 83, who says he has not had a bite to eat for 70 years, was put under constant surveillance to test his astonishing claims by a team of 30 military medical staff.

During a 15 day stay in a hospital in the city of Ahmedabad, India — he astounded doctors by not eating, drinking or going to the bathroom.

“We still do not know how he survives,” neurologist Sudhir Shah said at the end of the experiment. “It is still a mystery what kind of phenomenon this is.”

The yogi was sealed in a ward for the study initiated by India’s Defense Research and Development Organization (DRDO)….

“If Jani does not derive energy from food and water, he must be doing that from energy sources around him, sunlight being one,” Shah said. “As medical practitioners, we cannot shut our eyes to possibilities, to a source of energy other than calories.”

Fox News does not inquire how a man who “must be” deriving sustenance from “energy sources around him, sunlight being one” could gain that sustenance if he were “sealed in a ward for the study,” a ward depicted in photographs as having tiny windows covered with gauzy curtains. Neither does Fox News consider the contradiction between their most recent statement that Jani was “sealed in a ward for the study” and their report of April 29 that “a mobile camera films him when he goes outside.”

In another discrepancy, the April 29 report from Fox News asserted he would be in the experiment for “three weeks”; yesterday’s Fox News report indicated without remark that the end came after 15 days. The April 29 report asserted that “Since the experiment began on April 22, Jani has had no food or water”; other reports at the end of the experiment describe Prahlad Jani as having contact with water through “periodic gargling and bathing” beginning on the 5th day of the study.

Fox News makes no reference to the availability of experimental data, no reference to any independent confirmation of the results, no reference to the revelation that the research unit involved in this experiment refused to allow an independent monitor. Why include these matters in the report when there’s a gee-whiz story to be told?

8 thoughts on “Credulity over Credibility: Fox News Flubs the Prahlad Jani Story”

  1. Juniper says:

    That’s very unscientific for a three-week experiment to suddenly be changed to a 15-day study. What happened? Did the guru go into a state of medical shock?

    1. ramone says:

      twenty-one days or fifteen days, who cares? try not eating or drinking for even three days and see how you feel. if there is any truth to this it is totally astonishing. a life force that 99.99999% of the world’s population knows nothing about, this needs further investigation.

      1. Juniper says:

        Oh, it needs investigation, all right. Investigation for fraud. Scientists don’t exclude outside parties from engaging in scrutiny of an experiment. They invite it. The Prahlad Jani scam proved that it was not a scientific experiment when it didn’t allow anyone else to confirm its methodology.

        How can people fall for this hokum?

        Real science doesn’t set up an experiment and then change the standards half way through in order to make the experiment look successful. That’s what frauds do.

        1. Jacob says:

          How do we know the standards changed? I agree this is more than likly a hoax but that is as far as we can take it. This is a different culture. Does one report have business days and another include weekends? I think it is silly to attack before you know what is going on.

          1. Jim says:

            You’re right, Jacob, it is silly. No, one report doesn’t have business days and the other weekends. We know this because 15 calendar days passed between the beginning of the supposed experiment (April 22) and the announcement of its completion (May 6-7, depending on which local time to which you refer).

          2. maus says:

            “This is a different culture.”

            Reality does not change when viewed from a different prism.

          3. Darielle says:
      2. maus says:

        “if there is any truth to this it is totally astonishing.”

        You’re one of the dumbest people alive.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Psst... what kind of person doesn't support pacifism?

Fight the Republican beast!