Irregular Times Diaries: Unfit Discussion

In a time of the spring, old paths are obscured and new growth begins.

March 9, 2007

End to the War in a Year and a Half?!?

by @ 8:05 am. Filed under democrats, election 2008, legislation, war and peace

I wish I could say that I heard the news this morning with disbelief. Sadly, it’s become all too believable.

The Democrats in the House of Representatives have come up with a plan to end the war a year and a half from now.

Look, this plan is better than not ending the war at all, but why have it end a year and a half from now? I mean, if the Iraq War needs to be ended because it isn’t working now, what good will it do to have the war go on for another year and a half? What possible good could be accomplished from that?

Nothing good for the soldiers trapped over there. Nothing good for Iraq.

Something very good for the Democrats. See, the deadline to have American soldiers out of Iraq would be September 2008. Think hard now. What else is happening in the autumn of 2008?

That’s right: The elections. It’s not just the presidential election time. It’s also time for congressional elections.

So, the last American soldiers would leave Iraq just in time for Democrats to get credit for ending the war, but not with enough time for the Democrats to be blamed if things go to hell in a handbasket as a result.

This plan is an example of political maneuvering of the worst kind.

I want the war to end, just like most Americans do. I do not want the war to be stretched out a year and a half more by the Democrats for the sake of political gain.

Nancy Pelosi ought to be ashamed of herself.

1 Stars2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars

188 Votes | Average: 2.95 out of 5188 Votes | Average: 2.95 out of 5188 Votes | Average: 2.95 out of 5188 Votes | Average: 2.95 out of 5188 Votes | Average: 2.95 out of 5 (188 votes, average: 2.95 out of 5)

9 Responses to “End to the War in a Year and a Half?!?”

  1. Jim Says:

    Well, do they mean that all the Americans will be out in a year and a half, or that the process of winding down the war will begin in a year and a half? It seems to me that the two would be very different, and it seems from what you write that it’s the former, not the latter. Starting now and leaving slowly might be the safest way to go, not just for Americans but for Iraqi citizens, too.

    I have in mind Cincinnati, where police responded to complaints about racial profiling and other issues by simply and very abruptly stopping their patrols in black neighborhoods. The results of such abrupt withdrawal were pretty disruptive. I worry that removing American forces abruptly would lead to more chaos than necessary.

    I disagree with you here. I think there’s a distinction between a war and an occupation, and I think that what’s going on with the Americans in Iraq now is an occupation, and I think that abruptly ending an occupation could lead to a lot more bloodshed than slowly and carefully ending that occupation.

  2. jclifford Says:

    You really think there’s a need for a year and half? I could understand six months, or even nine months, but doesn’t the timing seem awfully suspicious to you?

  3. Jim Says:

    The thing is, I’m not a military expert, so I don’t know. But it seems reasonable to me that it might take a while. It seems reasonable to me that it might take five years to leave Iraq and not have the whole thing implode. I mean, there are still peacekeepers in Bosnia to make sure everybody doesn’t kill each other.

    The war obviously should never have been started. But the task of ending an occupation without really fucking over the people who are left behind doesn’t seem to have as easy an answer to me. The analogy I have in my mind is of a big pile of pick-up sticks.

  4. Peregrin Wood Says:

    Jim, you’re starting out with the assumption that it is possible to end the occupation of Iraq without fucking over the people of Iraq. What if we stay for five more years, keep on killing while we’re there, and then it turns even worse afterwards anyway?

    What if getting out quicker would actually end the violence quicker? That’s possible too.

  5. Ralph Says:

    Maybe the Democrats ought to have some hearings where they DO bring in military experts, economists, historians, veteran diplomats, etc. I would really like to click on CSPAN and see an authority on Vietnam or Algeria talking in real factual detail about the nuts and bolts of ending an occupation.

    I think we’re quickly coming to a consensus that our next military challenge will be to end the occupation. Too bad we’re not all gung-ho about the ending like we were about the beginning. Well, I’ll start:

    Woo-hoo! We’re gonna withdraw from an extended occupation of hostile territory with as few negative consequences as possible! Know why? Because America KICKS ASS! USA! USA!

  6. Jim Says:

    Well, Peregrin, I’m thinking of the fucked-over-ness of the people of Iraq as a variable. It’s possible for them to be more fucked, and it’s possible for them to be less fucked. And I think that a precipitous, speedy pull-out might be more deadly for the people of Iraq.

  7. Peregrin Wood Says:

    Here’s where I see the odds differently than you. It MIGHT be hard for the Iraqis for us to pull out in the really-not-so-quick six-to-nine month period I would prefer. What’s going on for the Iraqis NOW, under our occupation, is hard. I’d rather take the chance, for the sake of Iraqis and Americans alike, than prolong the status quo any longer.

  8. Laurie O Says:

    But here is the thing you haven’t even considered oh blind ones. They (our oh so spineless dems) are wanting to pull out all COMBAT TROOPS from Iraq. There has been nothing said about a total troop withdrawal. There is a difference.

    There are no combat troops in Kosovo or Bosnia or Korea……..the key, as usual, is in the wording. No combat troops means it becomes a stabilization force and that can be done with admin personnel, and any other non-combat forces which is 2/3rds of the armed forces.

    Again, the wording, you forgot to read the fine print.

  9. Laurie O Says:

    http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17516954/ sorry, my source.

Leave a Reply

Register or Log In

  • Register

  • Login

    newsletter:

    Enter your e-mail address here to receive our monthly e-mail newsletter:

    yellow star diary storiesTop Article Last Week


    Will They Call Him Joseph Robinette Biden?: 3.09

    Writers Last Week


    flippant
    Curious Sam
    jclifford
    Barley

    Highest Rated Articles


  • Where Are You, O Compliant and Fecund Conservative Christian Women? (4.31 Stars)

  • 50 Kilometer Wide UFO Enters the Solar System (3.73 Stars)

  • Mycology ID Help Me (3.47 Stars)

  • Big Box Sarah Palin (3.45 Stars)

  • Christian Hindu friendship for universal spirituality (3.37 Stars)

  • A Personal Question (3.37 Stars)

  • IRAQ BODY COUNT – ONGOING – 7/17/07 (3.31 Stars)

  • IRAQ BODY COUNT – ONGOING – 8/26/07 (3.28 Stars)

  • Kathleen Sebelius Saves America From Filth (3.28 Stars)

  • Face the Facts about Prayer (3.26 Stars)

  • Why Should We Ever Trust You Again? (3.26 Stars)

  • If You Read No Other Diary Entry (3.26 Stars)


  • partners:

    stamping clockIrregular Times
    Irregular Books
    Irregular News
    Progressive Patriots
    That's My Congress
    Irregular Links
    Irregular Goods

    bumper stickers:

    New Sticker Designs
    Bulk Discount Stickers
    Anti-Bush
    Anti-War
    Peace
    Liberal
    Supreme Court
    State Politics
    Local Politics
    Environmental
    Pro-Science
    President 2008

    buttons and magnets:

    jungaloo grit goblin New Button Designs
    Anti-Bush
    State Politics
    Local Politics
    Environment
    Heretical
    Gay and Lesbian
    Anti-War
    Liberal
    President 2008
    Anti-McCain
    Pro-Choice

    ethical organic t-shirts:

    Anti-War
    Godless
    Liberal
    Miscellaneous
    Sexuality

    sweatshop-free shirts:

    Progressive Moral Values
    Presidential Campaign
    Anti-War Shirts
    Local Liberal Shirts
    State Politics Shirts
    Environmentalist Shirts
    Artistic Activists
    Babies for Obama
    Liberal Kids Clothes

    other goods:

    Tote Bags made in the USA
    Posters
    Postcards
    Greeting Cards
    Text Catalog

    archives:

    March 2007
    S M T W T F S
    « Feb   Apr »
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    25262728293031

    other:

    RSS 2.0
    Comments RSS 2.0
  • Register

  • Login
  • About
  • Ask for Help
  • FAQ
  • Posting a Diary
  • Report Abusive Behavior
  • Rules of the Road
  • Irregular Times Main Page


    The Irregular Times Diaries are brought to you by Irregular Times, the place for news unfit to print.

    search the diaries:

    Latest Diary Comments


    Sarah Palin Couldn't Keep Her Business Running  (3 entries)
    Gag me, Jay Camp, myrene oconnor

    Will They Call Him Joseph Robinette Biden?  (1 entries)
    con

    Saving the Dove  (1 entries)
    Tom

    Bush to Lift Executive Ban on Offshore Drilling  (2 entries)
    jclifford, Charles

    Mocking God  (63 entries)
    Scott, Damen, Ralph, Damen [...]

    Tell Me About Salvia Divinorum, the Legal Hallucinogen  (78 entries)
    stan, Dawn, Andy, Andy [...]

    Words of Wisdom from a Flippant Website  (2 entries)
    Damen, Benjamin Franklin

    Where Are You, O Compliant and Fecund Conservative Christian Women?  (5 entries)
    Ralph, Anonymousse, Ralph, Hippo [...]

    categories:

    Politics


    The Real G.O.P.
    The Ribald Reign of King George II U.S. House Ratings
    U.S. Senate Ratings
    Irregular States

    Recent Articles:

    Interview with Kat Swift - Green Party candidate for President in 2008

    Is America Ready to Elect a President With a Brain?

    Burt's Bees Are Now Swimming In Clorox

    John Edwards Gives Good Information On Big Pharma Bad Behavior

    The National Pork Board Gets Weird About Muskrats

    Benjamin Franklin on Liberty and Small Safety

    Fathers Marry Daughters in Weird Right Wing Rituals

    The Virgin Mary Challenge

    Clinton Obama Campaign Gear

    Right Wing Values, Sexual Insecurity and Quick Impalement - strange insights from NewsMax advertisements

    Republican Senators kill an independent commission to investigate secret torture prisons set up by George W. Bush

    The latest Code Orange Alert from the Department of Homeland Insecurity: America may be targeted by kitchen table terrorists

    Are you an American liberal?

    The invisible activist

    A New President: Bumper Stickers for candidates in 2008

    Peace, Security and Fear


    Magniloquence Against War

    Recent Articles:

    Russell Feingold Speaks: The President Broke the Law

    War is not moderate

    Corpse pornography reflects the values of America's gruesome crusade

    Are Democrats too lazy to investigate the war in Iraq?

    A failure of Defense: The Bush Duds

    Faith and Skepticism


    False Witness
    Further Than Atheism
    Credulity Studies

    Recent Articles:

    Archive of Holocaust Comics from the Iranian Newspaper Hamshahri

    Archive of Mohammed Comics from the Danish Newspaper Jyllands Posten

    Jesus is Coming, but is he in the yellow pages?

    The Giant Scorpions of Science versus the Reruns of Religion

    Save Our Marriages! Mass chaos as Connecticuters flee westward

    Irregular Times resources on evolution, Creationism, and Intelligent Design

    Vote With Christ: an empirical guide

    Counter right wing fundamentalists' strident attacks with light hearted satire

    Pro-science Bumper Stickers, to defend science from faith-based zealotry.

    Covet Your Neighbor's Slave: The Ten Commandments and Slavery in politics today

    Online Resources: Secular Americans Against Bush

    The Environment


    Irregular Growth

    Recent Articles:

    Irregular Oceans - our articles following the crisis in Earth's marine ecosystems

    Celebrate World Ocean Day

    Considering Blown beds and gardens bereft of weeds

    Of Deer Fences and Deference

    In the glare of garden lights

    In Montana, Pesticide Burns

    Media


    Splintered Speech

    Recent Articles:

    Bush sets up secret torture prisons, so I try to say wake up and smell the coffee in a movie

    Ice Cream Promotes Male Virility, and other wisdom from medical advertising

    Explore the iconic insanity of Republican imagery

    Economy


    Funny Money

    Recent Articles:

    Irregular marketing - are you willing to buy it?

    Looking down on a Chicago bridge

    The brutal Republican concept of Social Security reform is revealed on a crusading t-shirt

    Finding the Fussy Elites - leaving a trail of gold foil, heirloom cigar boxes, and custom-etched pocket watches behind them

    An Overnight Blight: Why Progressives Pack Parcel Post

    Irregular Bin


    Our Remainders
    Wandering Aimlessly

    Recent Articles:

    Loonies for Mike Huckabee

    Senator Russ Feingold Stands for Freedom against Fear of the Patriot Act

    Handbook, My Ass: a review of James Carville's latest book

    Huygens probe finds evidence of intelligent life on Titan!

    An Irregular Reading (audio): The Hat in the Cat. What is Dr. Seuss backwards?

    A Dream of Dragons - Red fire battles blue water to own a bleak land

    70 queries. 0.869 seconds