Sunday, 12 of February of 2012

Irregular Times Diaries: Unfit Discussion

In a time of the spring, old paths are obscured and new growth begins.

• About
• Ask for Help
• FAQ
• Posting a Diary
• Report Abusive Behavior
• Rules of the Road

Print

Hillary Clinton Doesn’t Need To Win Iowa To Win

Which kind of leader would you rather have for President - the kind who loses in second place, or the kind who wins even in third place? Hillary Clinton is the clear choice for voters today.

John Edwards supporters ought to be ashamed of themselves for bragging about the endorsement from Ralph Nader. Have they forgotten how Ralph Nader threw the 2000 presidential election to George W. Bush? Now that Ralph Nader is endorsing John Edwards, a vote for Edwards is practically a vote for Bush.

Besides, John Edwards has really put all of his cards on the table. It’s Iowa or nothing for John Edwards, because he’s invested his campaign’s wealth there, organizing in the caucuses. If John Edwards doesn’t get first place in Iowa today, his campaign is dead in the water.

Hillary Clinton, on the other hand, doesn’t need to win Iowa at all in order to win the Democratic presidential nomination. Even if she comes in third place in the Iowa caucuses, it’s a sign of strength in her campaign, which invested little in Iowa.

Which kind of leader would you rather have for President – the kind who loses in second place, or the kind who wins even in third place? Hillary Clinton is the clear choice for voters today.

---

Date: January 3, 2008

Author: Proud Partisan

Categories: democrats, election 2008, politics

Tags: caucuses, clinton, edwards, hillary, iowa, john, nader, ralph

(315 votes, average: 2.87 out of 5)

 Loading ...

Leave a comment

Comments RSS TrackBack 7 comments

• 

  Isaac Laquedem

  in January 4th, 2008 @ 17:32

  I agree with you that Senator Clinton didn’t need to win Iowa, but she did need to finish second to maintain the image of inevitability that she wanted to have for the nomination race. She put a fair amount of effort into Iowa – she visited the state more times than most of the other Democrats, and about as much as Obama and Biden. The only Democratic candidate who visited Iowa more often was Edwards. Senator Clinton’s defeat in Iowa is at least a hint that her campaign might turn out to be a regional, rather than a national, phenomenon.

  http://www.iowapolitics.com/1009/caucus08.html

  ---

• 

  Isaac Laquedem

  in January 4th, 2008 @ 17:34

  I don’t follow your logic when you argue that coming in third shows more strength than coming in second.

  ---

• 

  jerseydem

  in January 4th, 2008 @ 21:48

  It’s true, Hillary did not need to win Iowa, and I’ll even go further and say she does not need to win N.H. or S. Carolina either. What will really matter is what happens on SuperTuesday.

  Hillary’s campaign knew that Iowa would be very difficult for her to win. I give her credit for deciding to participate in the primary there, unlike Bill in 1991 and Rudy this year. I don’t think anyone is counting Rudy out of the race just because he got 0 delegates from Iowa.

  Speaking of delegates, it seems that Hillary pretty much did come in 2nd in Iowa at least when it comes to delegates. She got 15 vs. Edwards’s 14 and Obama’s 16. When we look at the nitty-gritty outcome of the Iowa caucus, ie delegate numbers, we can easily see that she’s doing fine thus far.

  Another important point to keep in mind: the potential impact of SUPERDELEGATES. The Democratic Party gives states a total of 796 superdelegates –mainly members of Congress, other elected officials and DNC members, who are free to support any candidate at the convention, regardless of the outcomes of the primaries and caucuses.

  Although most superdelegates contacted by the AP before the Iowa caucuses were undecided, of the 251 who have endorsed a candidate, Clinton leads with 160, compared to 59 for Obama and 32 for former Sen. John Edwards.

  ---

• 

  Iroquois

  in January 4th, 2008 @ 23:25

  I’m currently about an hour drive from the New Hampshire border. What they’re doing up here is using their cellphones to show people an unflattering Hillary picture with wrinkles and saying “would you vote for THAT?”

  These are the same people who start off a sentence, “I’m not against a woman for president but..”

  ---

• 

  Frank Liberal

  in January 5th, 2008 @ 17:10

  Of course, jerseydem, Hillary Clinton’s campaign didn’t use to give this spin you’re referring to that Iowa would be tough for her to win. It used to be that she regarded herself as having the strategy of establishing invincibility there. That kind of turned the Iowans off.

  Also, your analysis ignores that what happens on Super Tuesday is strongly shaped by what happens in the primaries before Super Tuesday. If Hillary Clinton loses New Hampshire on Tuesday, even New York State might be put in play on Super Tuesday…

  …and she was booed by a collection of Democrats in New Hampshire.

  ---

• 

  jerseydem

  in January 5th, 2008 @ 18:06

  Have to disagree with you Frank Liberal. The Super Tuesday dynamics have changed now that there are more states participating. Unless you have a crystal ball, of course. We can’t rely on what has happened in the past.

  What we do know is that Hillary came out of Iowa with just 1 less delegate than Obama; she has 3x more superdelegates endorsing her (160 to 60) and in the end, whoever wins will have to come up with 2000 something delegates to get the nomination. So, just get over Iowa already, will you?

  ---

• 

  Isaac Laquedem

  in January 7th, 2008 @ 12:56

  Iowa doesn’t have enough delegates to matter. The candidates themselves weren’t (before the caucuses) framing Iowa as a victory for the winner of the most delegates, but as a victory for the winner of the most participants — sort of a test run for the states with primaries. Iowa’s blow to Senator Clinton’s campaign is its suggestion that Senator Obama is the stronger Democratic candidate in the farm states.

  ---

Irregular Times Diaries: Unfit Discussion uses WordPress as content manager.